'06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

I know this is a liberty forum, and I know my username is "wannaB4" but hear me out.

2006 2.5T WRX is the first generation of the new 2.5lt engines
QUESTION - are these crap, have any known major or minor issues??? I make a rule not buying the first gen of anything (iPhone anyone?) anyone had experience with them?

2004 GT lib - driven a number of B4's and they fell very tight (I put it down to my driving skills, and maybe a little to the Bill-stein suspension:neo:)
QUESTION - are the GT's softer b/c of lack of Bill's-stein (haven't test-drove one yet, but have heard this)???

For reasons beyond my control I need a car - there aren't any B4's in Vic that fit what I want  (manual, 03, blue or silver, full service history w/ major done, less than 100K km's - Mick your's in Syd looks awesome but diff color and isn't in VIC). And also going to get through work lease - maybe. So this is where I'm at.

Cheers,

WannaB4
useravatar

Posts:  18

Status:  Offline

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

WannaB4;172732 wrote:

For reasons beyond my control I need a car - there aren't any B4's in Vic that fit what I want  (manual, 03, blue or silver, full service history w/ major done, less than 100K km's - Mick your's in Syd looks awesome but diff color and isn't in VIC). And also going to get through work lease - maybe. So this is where I'm at.

Cheers,
You might have to be less specific if your going for a used car, espeicially a rare car like a B4.

I've never even been in a GT, but i have read they are softer but nicer inside. The WRX has been canned a lot since they came out so i would think more than twice before getting one.

hawks123
useravatar

Posts:  914

Status:  Offline

If it's Broke, Use a Cable Tie.

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

The GT has got sofer suspension but it by no means a boat. Simple upgrade is some STi pink springs (common as cow crap). If you want a manual GT you'll have to look out for an 05 onwards, 04 is auto/sports shift only.

Kevlar GT
State Rep
useravatar

Posts:  563

Status:  Offline

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

Just buy my B4 = Win

The GT is more the styler than the power house.

The WRX as stated is like marrying a  sl*t, everyone has had their fun in it, and your gonna be stuck with it.

XXB4XX
useravatar

Posts:  5397

Status:  Offline

Sold the Subaru, replaced it with a Honda.. but all I know is Subaru's! (and Holden V8's of course):secret:

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

I have not heard of any issues with the 06 wrx's.
Even though they are the first wrx with the 2.5, foz's had the 2.5 for a few years before then, and they have had no issues.

rxliberty2000
State Rep
useravatar

Posts:  3857

Status:  Offline

2000 Liberty GT-B

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

I would go the 06 wrx... depending month will still retain factory warrenty. I dont think you will have to worry about someone else having flogged it as much, generally the newer ones are owned by older people who tend to maintain them better. There is 200% more chance the B4 will have had it tits flogged of it than the wrx.

Only problem will the 2.5 is it can be weak if worked alot. But a front mount and flash tune get very very good results if that is far enough for you. 06 will also have the bullet proof 6 speed drive line, B4 doesnt.

Liberty would be nice but they are alittle soft and $$$ for a manual.

14nce
useravatar

Posts:  266

Status:  Offline

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

Thanks for the advice guys, muchly appreciated

hawks123;172790 wrote:

You might have to be less specific if your going for a used car, espeicially a rare car like a B4.

I've never even been in a GT, but i have read they are softer but nicer inside. The WRX has been canned a lot since they came out so i would think more than twice before getting one.
Yeah, I know I'm a pickie barst*$d, love how sorted the B4's have been on the road, but drove a '05 WRX (last of the 2.0T) and it really impressed me.

XXB4XX wrote:

Just buy my B4 = Win

The GT is more the styler than the power house.

The WRX as stated is like marrying a  sl*t, everyone has had their fun in it, and your gonna be stuck with it.
Thanks XXB4XX, had a good look at your's, but leasing companies frown on mod's and really need to sort this this wknd (a cbf heading up to Syd). Only looking at one owner WRX's from '03-'05 me thinks (decided the '06 shape is a bit naf), and if I'm not happy I'm going to find a B4 and stuff the farkn leasing.

WannaB4
useravatar

Posts:  18

Status:  Offline

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

i cant comment on too much of the 2.5's other than what ive read and heard ....breaking too easily at low k's... piston liners and other issues...i will dig out the uk stuff ive read...as for gt's and 2.0L wrx ... i had a wee run with a wrx and my gtb (same as b4 engine/powerwise) and up to 160kph there wasnt much in it,...after that, the twin turbo just gained its legs and off like a gazelle.... i eased off at circa 145mph....circa 240kph and he wasnt too far behind at that point but was disappearing fast...he got more than he bargained for......needless to say this was in a controlled environment in the uk.....oh , and the legacy is a far more comfortable car in every way....refined, smooth, discreet, and depending on yer age, perfect !

rab
useravatar

Posts:  18

Status:  Offline

92 rs liberty..supposed to be ! :lol:

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

WannaB4;172732 wrote:

I know this is a liberty forum, and I know my username is "wannaB4" but hear me out.

2006 2.5T WRX is the first generation of the new 2.5lt engines
QUESTION - are these crap, have any known major or minor issues??? I make a rule not buying the first gen of anything (iPhone anyone?) anyone had experience with them?

2004 GT lib - driven a number of B4's and they fell very tight (I put it down to my driving skills, and maybe a little to the Bill-stein suspension:neo:)
QUESTION - are the GT's softer b/c of lack of Bill's-stein (haven't test-drove one yet, but have heard this)???

For reasons beyond my control I need a car - there aren't any B4's in Vic that fit what I want  (manual, 03, blue or silver, full service history w/ major done, less than 100K km's - Mick your's in Syd looks awesome but diff color and isn't in VIC). And also going to get through work lease - maybe. So this is where I'm at.

Cheers,
Having owned a B4 and GT, I will share my experiences primarily around these two vehicles.

'99 RSK JDM (B4) manual - Great handling car, very nimble and predictable. Chassis rigidity is excellent and motor actually feels like it has 206kW (JDM spec), despite the power gap between 3000-4000rpms. However, like it has been discussed, this can be improved with a good tune.

'04 GT automatic - more geared towards comfort, rather than outright handling. Chassis rigidity is an improvement over the B4. The automatic 180kW (manual gets 190kW, only available in 2005 onwards) doesn't feel quite feel like 180kW, but is probably deceptive because of the improved NVH and refinement of the motor. The vehicle I had, had a JDM/STi tune, but still didn't feel like 200kW. However, there are many modification options due to its similarities to the WRX motor. Suspension can feel very floaty, especially on rebound, but can be fixed with a set of Bilstein, which I had for a few weeks on the car.

WRX '06 2.5L - from my limited understanding, the motor is definitely not first generation - has been in Forester XT. Won engine of the year awards, so in standard form is reliable and no sloutch. Modification options are plentiful, but need to be careful as the EJ25 block is weak, due to its open deck design and thinner bore walls. WRX suspension is great for track work, but the geometry design is similar to the Gen1 Liberty's and IMO is outdated.

AWD_1993
useravatar

Posts:  445

Status:  Offline

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

yup, pretty much on the money .... b4 is a great car..... blitzen is gorgeous too....:triniti:

rab
useravatar

Posts:  18

Status:  Offline

92 rs liberty..supposed to be ! :lol:

Re: '06 WRX v. '04 GT v. B4 question - hear me out

  Top of Page

Well I've recently bought an '04 GT and even though it's got the get up and go it's definately more of a cruiser. Grips well and stays pretty flat through corners but it's not a performance car like a wrx. But really nice inside.
I looked at a B4 breifly but couldn't deal with the blue interior. But that's just me.

Trist
useravatar

Posts:  18

Status:  Offline

Board Info

Board Stats:   Total Users: 12429  Total Topics: 19474  Total Polls: 12  Total Posts: 151087914  Total Posts Today: 3
User Info:   Newest User :  Beans GT   Members Online: 0   Guests Online: 110
Online  There are no members online
Generated in 0.628 sec. Queries: 106
RSS - Subscribe to ozLiberty feeds Twitter - follow our tweets MySpace - Join our groupFacebook - Join our group